OpenID was never intended as a general login system. That's just a widespread misattribution. (Which SE has clearly contributed to.)
Shutting it down habitually will have some ripple effects outside of SE/SO, however. It's not just Stack-specific bots using the OpenID consumer. Many users here do utilize the OpenID provider too.
- For instance I get the most useful flags on //freshcode.club from users with ana StackExchange OpenID handle.
- They're not just more frequent than Yahoo logonslogins, but inherently more trustworthy. IMO.
Just measuring active SE logins falls a bit short of its actual impact. Code complexity might not warrant it. But all the maintenance and effort done over the years, wasn't spent on the local scope alone.