Trusted Types: Prototype for hacking. #6457

chromium-wpt-export-bot · 2017-07-04T13:57:45Z

After talking with some folks about xtof's 1, I think there's something
there that browsers are uniquely positioned to help out with. This patch
starts sketching out what a set of safe types might look like, and what
it might feel like for a developer to lock themselves out of raw string
assignments to typical XSS sinks like location.href or el.innerHTML.

This patch implements a first pass at TrustedHTML and TrustedURL,
along with updates to a few sinks to use these new types. It's by no
means a complete implementation, but should give us enough to play
around with while we experiment with library authors to see how the
layering might work.

Explainer: https://github.com/mikewest/trusted-types
Intent to Implement: https://groups.google.com/a/chromium.org/d/msg/blink-dev/qbOrXp9g3B8/hziymUnHAQAJ

P.S. This patch looks huge and ugly, but the majority of the changes are
the renamings of set{Inner,Outer}HTML that touch a million tests.

Bug: 739170
Cq-Include-Trybots: master.tryserver.chromium.linux:linux_layout_tests_slimming_paint_v2
Change-Id: I65e5add5cc7fcbc17f97ca8b737d7a3e1d8cad3b
Reviewed-on: https://chromium-review.googlesource.com/559061
Commit-Queue: Mike West mkwst@chromium.org
Reviewed-by: Yoav Weiss yoav@yoav.ws
Cr-Commit-Position: refs/heads/master@{#503113}

wpt-pr-bot

Already reviewed downstream.

w3c-bots · 2017-07-04T14:16:04Z

View the complete job log.

Firefox (nightly)

Testing web-platform-tests at revision 048d9c4
Using browser at version BuildID 20170704100254; SourceStamp fef489e8c2a193dde885adc48deb74cc883a5881
Starting 10 test iterations
All results were stable

All results

11 tests ran

/safe-html-types/SafeHTML.tentative.html

Subtest	Results	Messages
	OK
`Basic escaping.`	FAIL	`SafeHTML is not defined`
`Basic unsafe construction.`	FAIL	`SafeHTML is not defined`

/safe-html-types/SafeURL.tentative.html

Subtest	Results	Messages
	OK
`Basic processing: safe URL, safe construction.`	FAIL	`SafeURL is not defined`
`Basic processing: safe URL, unsafe construction.`	FAIL	`SafeURL is not defined`
`Basic processing: javascript URL, safe construction.`	FAIL	`SafeURL is not defined`
`Basic processing: javascript URL, unsafe construction.`	FAIL	`SafeURL is not defined`
`Basic processing: external protocol URL, safe construction.`	FAIL	`SafeURL is not defined`
`Basic processing: external protocol URL, unsafe construction.`	FAIL	`SafeURL is not defined`

/safe-html-types/block-string-assignment-to-innerHTML.tentative.html

Subtest	Results	Messages
	OK
`innerHTML = string throws.`	FAIL	`assert_throws: function "_ => {\n d.innerHTML = "Fail.";\n }" did not throw`
`innerHTML = SafeHTML.escape().`	FAIL	`SafeHTML is not defined`
`innerHTML = SafeHTML.unsafelyCreate().`	FAIL	`SafeHTML is not defined`

/safe-html-types/block-string-assignment-to-insertAdjacentHTML.tentative.html

Subtest	Results	Messages
	OK
`insertAdjacentHTML(string) throws.`	FAIL	`assert_throws: function "_ => {\n d.insertAdjacentHTML('beforebegin', "<p>Fail</p>");\n }" did not throw`
`insertAdjacentHTML = SafeHTML.escape().`	FAIL	`SafeHTML is not defined`
`insertAdjacentHTML = SafeHTML.unsafelyCreate().`	FAIL	`SafeHTML is not defined`

/safe-html-types/block-string-assignment-to-location-href.tentative.html

Subtest	Results	Messages
	OK
`location.href = string throws`	FAIL	`SafeURL is not defined`
`Basic processing: safe URL, safe construction.`	FAIL	`SafeURL is not defined`
`Basic processing: safe URL, unsafe construction.`	FAIL	`SafeURL is not defined`
`Basic processing: javascript URL, safe construction.`	FAIL	`SafeURL is not defined`
`Basic processing: javascript URL, unsafe construction.`	FAIL	`SafeURL is not defined`

/safe-html-types/block-string-assignment-to-outerHTML.tentative.html

Subtest	Results	Messages
	OK
`outerHTML = string throws.`	FAIL	`assert_throws: function "_ => {\n d.outerHTML = "Fail.";\n }" did not throw`
`outerHTML = SafeHTML.escape().`	FAIL	`SafeHTML is not defined`
`outerHTML = SafeHTML.unsafelyCreate().`	FAIL	`SafeHTML is not defined`

/safe-html-types/document-write.tentative.html

Subtest	Results	Messages
	OK
`document.write(SafeHTML).`	FAIL	`SafeHTML is not defined`

/safe-html-types/innerHTML.tentative.html

Subtest	Results	Messages
	OK
`innerHTML = SafeHTML.escape().`	FAIL	`SafeHTML is not defined`
`innerHTML = SafeHTML.unsafelyCreate().`	FAIL	`SafeHTML is not defined`

/safe-html-types/insertAdjacentHTML.tentative.html

Subtest	Results	Messages
	OK
`insertAdjacentHTML = SafeHTML.escape().`	FAIL	`SafeHTML is not defined`
`insertAdjacentHTML = SafeHTML.unsafelyCreate().`	FAIL	`SafeHTML is not defined`

/safe-html-types/location-href.tentative.html

Subtest	Results	Messages
	OK
`Basic processing: safe URL, safe construction.`	FAIL	`SafeURL is not defined`
`Basic processing: safe URL, unsafe construction.`	FAIL	`SafeURL is not defined`
`Basic processing: javascript URL, safe construction.`	FAIL	`SafeURL is not defined`
`Basic processing: javascript URL, unsafe construction.`	FAIL	`SafeURL is not defined`

/safe-html-types/outerHTML.tentative.html

Subtest	Results	Messages
	OK
`outerHTML = SafeHTML.escape().`	FAIL	`SafeHTML is not defined`
`outerHTML = SafeHTML.unsafelyCreate().`	FAIL	`SafeHTML is not defined`

w3c-bots · 2017-07-04T14:16:04Z

View the complete job log.

Sauce (safari)

Testing web-platform-tests at revision 048d9c4
Using browser at version 10.0
Starting 10 test iterations
All results were stable

All results

11 tests ran

/safe-html-types/SafeHTML.tentative.html

Subtest	Results	Messages
	OK
`Basic escaping.`	FAIL	`Can't find variable: SafeHTML`
`Basic unsafe construction.`	FAIL	`Can't find variable: SafeHTML`

/safe-html-types/SafeURL.tentative.html

Subtest	Results	Messages
	OK
`Basic processing: safe URL, safe construction.`	FAIL	`Can't find variable: SafeURL`
`Basic processing: safe URL, unsafe construction.`	FAIL	`Can't find variable: SafeURL`
`Basic processing: javascript URL, safe construction.`	FAIL	`Can't find variable: SafeURL`
`Basic processing: javascript URL, unsafe construction.`	FAIL	`Can't find variable: SafeURL`
`Basic processing: external protocol URL, safe construction.`	FAIL	`Can't find variable: SafeURL`
`Basic processing: external protocol URL, unsafe construction.`	FAIL	`Can't find variable: SafeURL`

/safe-html-types/block-string-assignment-to-innerHTML.tentative.html

Subtest	Results	Messages
	OK
`innerHTML = string throws.`	FAIL	`assert_throws: function "_ => {\n d.innerHTML = "Fail.";\n }" did not throw`
`innerHTML = SafeHTML.escape().`	FAIL	`Can't find variable: SafeHTML`
`innerHTML = SafeHTML.unsafelyCreate().`	FAIL	`Can't find variable: SafeHTML`

/safe-html-types/block-string-assignment-to-insertAdjacentHTML.tentative.html

Subtest	Results	Messages
	OK
`insertAdjacentHTML(string) throws.`	FAIL	`assert_throws: function "_ => {\n d.insertAdjacentHTML('beforebegin', "<p>Fail</p>");\n }" did not throw`
`insertAdjacentHTML = SafeHTML.escape().`	FAIL	`Can't find variable: SafeHTML`
`insertAdjacentHTML = SafeHTML.unsafelyCreate().`	FAIL	`Can't find variable: SafeHTML`

/safe-html-types/block-string-assignment-to-location-href.tentative.html

Subtest	Results	Messages
	OK
`location.href = string throws`	FAIL	`Can't find variable: SafeURL`
`Basic processing: safe URL, safe construction.`	FAIL	`Can't find variable: SafeURL`
`Basic processing: safe URL, unsafe construction.`	FAIL	`Can't find variable: SafeURL`
`Basic processing: javascript URL, safe construction.`	FAIL	`Can't find variable: SafeURL`
`Basic processing: javascript URL, unsafe construction.`	FAIL	`Can't find variable: SafeURL`

/safe-html-types/block-string-assignment-to-outerHTML.tentative.html

Subtest	Results	Messages
	OK
`outerHTML = string throws.`	FAIL	`assert_throws: function "_ => {\n d.outerHTML = "Fail.";\n }" did not throw`
`outerHTML = SafeHTML.escape().`	FAIL	`Can't find variable: SafeHTML`
`outerHTML = SafeHTML.unsafelyCreate().`	FAIL	`Can't find variable: SafeHTML`

/safe-html-types/document-write.tentative.html

Subtest	Results	Messages
	OK
`document.write(SafeHTML).`	FAIL	`Can't find variable: SafeHTML`

/safe-html-types/innerHTML.tentative.html

Subtest	Results	Messages
	OK
`innerHTML = SafeHTML.escape().`	FAIL	`Can't find variable: SafeHTML`
`innerHTML = SafeHTML.unsafelyCreate().`	FAIL	`Can't find variable: SafeHTML`

/safe-html-types/insertAdjacentHTML.tentative.html

Subtest	Results	Messages
	OK
`insertAdjacentHTML = SafeHTML.escape().`	FAIL	`Can't find variable: SafeHTML`
`insertAdjacentHTML = SafeHTML.unsafelyCreate().`	FAIL	`Can't find variable: SafeHTML`

/safe-html-types/location-href.tentative.html

Subtest	Results	Messages
	OK
`Basic processing: safe URL, safe construction.`	FAIL	`Can't find variable: SafeURL`
`Basic processing: safe URL, unsafe construction.`	FAIL	`Can't find variable: SafeURL`
`Basic processing: javascript URL, safe construction.`	FAIL	`Can't find variable: SafeURL`
`Basic processing: javascript URL, unsafe construction.`	FAIL	`Can't find variable: SafeURL`

/safe-html-types/outerHTML.tentative.html

Subtest	Results	Messages
	OK
`outerHTML = SafeHTML.escape().`	FAIL	`Can't find variable: SafeHTML`
`outerHTML = SafeHTML.unsafelyCreate().`	FAIL	`Can't find variable: SafeHTML`

w3c-bots · 2017-07-04T14:16:06Z

View the complete job log.

Chrome (unstable)

Testing web-platform-tests at revision 048d9c4
Using browser at version 61.0.3141.7 dev
Starting 10 test iterations
All results were stable

All results

11 tests ran

/safe-html-types/SafeHTML.tentative.html

Subtest	Results	Messages
	OK
`Basic escaping.`	FAIL	`SafeHTML is not defined`
`Basic unsafe construction.`	FAIL	`SafeHTML is not defined`

/safe-html-types/SafeURL.tentative.html

Subtest	Results	Messages
	OK
`Basic processing: safe URL, safe construction.`	FAIL	`SafeURL is not defined`
`Basic processing: safe URL, unsafe construction.`	FAIL	`SafeURL is not defined`
`Basic processing: javascript URL, safe construction.`	FAIL	`SafeURL is not defined`
`Basic processing: javascript URL, unsafe construction.`	FAIL	`SafeURL is not defined`
`Basic processing: external protocol URL, safe construction.`	FAIL	`SafeURL is not defined`
`Basic processing: external protocol URL, unsafe construction.`	FAIL	`SafeURL is not defined`

/safe-html-types/block-string-assignment-to-innerHTML.tentative.html

Subtest	Results	Messages
	OK
`innerHTML = string throws.`	FAIL	`assert_throws: function "_ => {\n d.innerHTML = "Fail.";\n }" did not throw`
`innerHTML = SafeHTML.escape().`	FAIL	`SafeHTML is not defined`
`innerHTML = SafeHTML.unsafelyCreate().`	FAIL	`SafeHTML is not defined`

/safe-html-types/block-string-assignment-to-insertAdjacentHTML.tentative.html

Subtest	Results	Messages
	OK
`insertAdjacentHTML(string) throws.`	FAIL	`assert_throws: function "_ => {\n d.insertAdjacentHTML('beforebegin', "<p>Fail</p>");\n }" did not throw`
`insertAdjacentHTML = SafeHTML.escape().`	FAIL	`SafeHTML is not defined`
`insertAdjacentHTML = SafeHTML.unsafelyCreate().`	FAIL	`SafeHTML is not defined`

/safe-html-types/block-string-assignment-to-location-href.tentative.html

Subtest	Results	Messages
	OK
`location.href = string throws`	FAIL	`SafeURL is not defined`
`Basic processing: safe URL, safe construction.`	FAIL	`SafeURL is not defined`
`Basic processing: safe URL, unsafe construction.`	FAIL	`SafeURL is not defined`
`Basic processing: javascript URL, safe construction.`	FAIL	`SafeURL is not defined`
`Basic processing: javascript URL, unsafe construction.`	FAIL	`SafeURL is not defined`

/safe-html-types/block-string-assignment-to-outerHTML.tentative.html

Subtest	Results	Messages
	OK
`outerHTML = string throws.`	FAIL	`assert_throws: function "_ => {\n d.outerHTML = "Fail.";\n }" did not throw`
`outerHTML = SafeHTML.escape().`	FAIL	`SafeHTML is not defined`
`outerHTML = SafeHTML.unsafelyCreate().`	FAIL	`SafeHTML is not defined`

/safe-html-types/document-write.tentative.html

Subtest	Results	Messages
	OK
`document.write(SafeHTML).`	FAIL	`SafeHTML is not defined`

/safe-html-types/innerHTML.tentative.html

Subtest	Results	Messages
	OK
`innerHTML = SafeHTML.escape().`	FAIL	`SafeHTML is not defined`
`innerHTML = SafeHTML.unsafelyCreate().`	FAIL	`SafeHTML is not defined`

/safe-html-types/insertAdjacentHTML.tentative.html

Subtest	Results	Messages
	OK
`insertAdjacentHTML = SafeHTML.escape().`	FAIL	`SafeHTML is not defined`
`insertAdjacentHTML = SafeHTML.unsafelyCreate().`	FAIL	`SafeHTML is not defined`

/safe-html-types/location-href.tentative.html

Subtest	Results	Messages
	OK
`Basic processing: safe URL, safe construction.`	FAIL	`SafeURL is not defined`
`Basic processing: safe URL, unsafe construction.`	FAIL	`SafeURL is not defined`
`Basic processing: javascript URL, safe construction.`	FAIL	`SafeURL is not defined`
`Basic processing: javascript URL, unsafe construction.`	FAIL	`SafeURL is not defined`

/safe-html-types/outerHTML.tentative.html

Subtest	Results	Messages
	OK
`outerHTML = SafeHTML.escape().`	FAIL	`SafeHTML is not defined`
`outerHTML = SafeHTML.unsafelyCreate().`	FAIL	`SafeHTML is not defined`

w3c-bots · 2017-07-04T14:16:06Z

View the complete job log.

Sauce (MicrosoftEdge)

Testing web-platform-tests at revision 048d9c4
Using browser at version 14.14393
Starting 10 test iterations
All results were stable

All results

11 tests ran

/safe-html-types/SafeHTML.tentative.html

Subtest	Results	Messages
	OK
`Basic escaping.`	FAIL	`'SafeHTML' is undefined`
`Basic unsafe construction.`	FAIL	`'SafeHTML' is undefined`

/safe-html-types/SafeURL.tentative.html

Subtest	Results	Messages
	OK
`Basic processing: safe URL, safe construction.`	FAIL	`'SafeURL' is undefined`
`Basic processing: safe URL, unsafe construction.`	FAIL	`'SafeURL' is undefined`
`Basic processing: javascript URL, safe construction.`	FAIL	`'SafeURL' is undefined`
`Basic processing: javascript URL, unsafe construction.`	FAIL	`'SafeURL' is undefined`
`Basic processing: external protocol URL, safe construction.`	FAIL	`'SafeURL' is undefined`
`Basic processing: external protocol URL, unsafe construction.`	FAIL	`'SafeURL' is undefined`

/safe-html-types/block-string-assignment-to-innerHTML.tentative.html

Subtest	Results	Messages
	OK
`innerHTML = string throws.`	FAIL	`assert_throws: function "_ => {\n d.innerHTML = "Fail.";\n }" did not throw`
`innerHTML = SafeHTML.escape().`	FAIL	`'SafeHTML' is undefined`
`innerHTML = SafeHTML.unsafelyCreate().`	FAIL	`'SafeHTML' is undefined`

/safe-html-types/block-string-assignment-to-insertAdjacentHTML.tentative.html

Subtest	Results	Messages
	OK
`insertAdjacentHTML(string) throws.`	FAIL	`assert_throws: function "_ => {\n d.insertAdjacentHTML('beforebegin', "<p>Fail</p>");\n }" did not throw`
`insertAdjacentHTML = SafeHTML.escape().`	FAIL	`'SafeHTML' is undefined`
`insertAdjacentHTML = SafeHTML.unsafelyCreate().`	FAIL	`'SafeHTML' is undefined`

/safe-html-types/block-string-assignment-to-location-href.tentative.html

Subtest	Results	Messages
	OK
`location.href = string throws`	FAIL	`'SafeURL' is undefined`
`Basic processing: safe URL, safe construction.`	FAIL	`'SafeURL' is undefined`
`Basic processing: safe URL, unsafe construction.`	FAIL	`'SafeURL' is undefined`
`Basic processing: javascript URL, safe construction.`	FAIL	`'SafeURL' is undefined`
`Basic processing: javascript URL, unsafe construction.`	FAIL	`'SafeURL' is undefined`

/safe-html-types/block-string-assignment-to-outerHTML.tentative.html

Subtest	Results	Messages
	OK
`outerHTML = string throws.`	FAIL	`assert_throws: function "_ => {\n d.outerHTML = "Fail.";\n }" did not throw`
`outerHTML = SafeHTML.escape().`	FAIL	`'SafeHTML' is undefined`
`outerHTML = SafeHTML.unsafelyCreate().`	FAIL	`'SafeHTML' is undefined`

/safe-html-types/document-write.tentative.html

Subtest	Results	Messages
	OK
`document.write(SafeHTML).`	FAIL	`'SafeHTML' is undefined`

/safe-html-types/innerHTML.tentative.html

Subtest	Results	Messages
	OK
`innerHTML = SafeHTML.escape().`	FAIL	`'SafeHTML' is undefined`
`innerHTML = SafeHTML.unsafelyCreate().`	FAIL	`'SafeHTML' is undefined`

/safe-html-types/insertAdjacentHTML.tentative.html

Subtest	Results	Messages
	OK
`insertAdjacentHTML = SafeHTML.escape().`	FAIL	`'SafeHTML' is undefined`
`insertAdjacentHTML = SafeHTML.unsafelyCreate().`	FAIL	`'SafeHTML' is undefined`

/safe-html-types/location-href.tentative.html

Subtest	Results	Messages
	OK
`Basic processing: safe URL, safe construction.`	FAIL	`'SafeURL' is undefined`
`Basic processing: safe URL, unsafe construction.`	FAIL	`'SafeURL' is undefined`
`Basic processing: javascript URL, safe construction.`	FAIL	`'SafeURL' is undefined`
`Basic processing: javascript URL, unsafe construction.`	FAIL	`'SafeURL' is undefined`

/safe-html-types/outerHTML.tentative.html

Subtest	Results	Messages
	OK
`outerHTML = SafeHTML.escape().`	FAIL	`'SafeHTML' is undefined`
`outerHTML = SafeHTML.unsafelyCreate().`	FAIL	`'SafeHTML' is undefined`

mikewest · 2017-07-05T08:08:20Z

(This isn't meant for review; it's meant for some discussion that could eventually lead to an explainer for even more discussion. Thanks for ignoring it!)

w3c-bots · 2017-09-18T16:42:22Z

Build PASSED

Started: 2017-09-20 11:46:59
Finished: 2017-09-20 11:54:36

View more information about this build on:

After talking with some folks about xtof's [1], I think there's something there that browsers are uniquely positioned to help out with. This patch starts sketching out what a set of safe types might look like, and what it might feel like for a developer to lock themselves out of raw string assignments to typical XSS sinks like `location.href` or `el.innerHTML`. This patch implements a first pass at `TrustedHTML` and `TrustedURL`, along with updates to a few sinks to use these new types. It's by no means a complete implementation, but should give us enough to play around with while we experiment with library authors to see how the layering might work. Explainer: https://github.com/mikewest/trusted-types Intent to Implement: https://groups.google.com/a/chromium.org/d/msg/blink-dev/qbOrXp9g3B8/hziymUnHAQAJ [1]: https://research.google.com/pubs/pub42934.html P.S. This patch looks huge and ugly, but the majority of the changes are the renamings of `set{Inner,Outer}HTML` that touch a million tests. Bug: 739170 Cq-Include-Trybots: master.tryserver.chromium.linux:linux_layout_tests_slimming_paint_v2 Change-Id: I65e5add5cc7fcbc17f97ca8b737d7a3e1d8cad3b Reviewed-on: https://chromium-review.googlesource.com/559061 Commit-Queue: Mike West <mkwst@chromium.org> Reviewed-by: Yoav Weiss <yoav@yoav.ws> Cr-Commit-Position: refs/heads/master@{#503113}

chromium-wpt-export-bot added chromium-export do not merge yet labels Jul 4, 2017

wpt-pr-bot added the safe-html-types label Jul 4, 2017

wpt-pr-bot approved these changes Jul 4, 2017

View reviewed changes

chromium-wpt-export-bot force-pushed the chromium-export-cl-I65e5add5cc7fcbc17f97ca8b737d7a3e1d8cad3b branch from 2b59cde to 16ae10f Compare July 5, 2017 07:02

chromium-wpt-export-bot force-pushed the chromium-export-cl-I65e5add5cc7fcbc17f97ca8b737d7a3e1d8cad3b branch from 16ae10f to 3a0861d Compare July 5, 2017 08:14

chromium-wpt-export-bot force-pushed the chromium-export-cl-I65e5add5cc7fcbc17f97ca8b737d7a3e1d8cad3b branch from 3a0861d to b161a19 Compare September 18, 2017 14:11

wpt-pr-bot added the trusted-types label Sep 18, 2017

chromium-wpt-export-bot changed the title ~~WIP: Explore adding some "safe" string types.~~ Sep 19, 2017

chromium-wpt-export-bot force-pushed the chromium-export-cl-I65e5add5cc7fcbc17f97ca8b737d7a3e1d8cad3b branch from b161a19 to 7f5f4d7 Compare September 19, 2017 07:09

mikewest mentioned this pull request Sep 19, 2017

Consider something like a "Trusted Type" system for DOM manipulation. whatwg/html#3052

Closed

chromium-wpt-export-bot force-pushed the chromium-export-cl-I65e5add5cc7fcbc17f97ca8b737d7a3e1d8cad3b branch 4 times, most recently from 0bc2a97 to 16fee82 Compare September 20, 2017 09:32

chromium-wpt-export-bot removed the do not merge yet label Sep 20, 2017

chromium-wpt-export-bot force-pushed the chromium-export-cl-I65e5add5cc7fcbc17f97ca8b737d7a3e1d8cad3b branch from 16fee82 to d1d335c Compare September 20, 2017 11:46

chromium-wpt-export-bot merged commit b08a29b into master Sep 20, 2017

chromium-wpt-export-bot deleted the chromium-export-cl-I65e5add5cc7fcbc17f97ca8b737d7a3e1d8cad3b branch September 20, 2017 12:01

Provide feedback

Saved searches

Use saved searches to filter your results more quickly

Trusted Types: Prototype for hacking. #6457

Trusted Types: Prototype for hacking. #6457

chromium-wpt-export-bot commented Jul 4, 2017 •

edited by wpt-pr-bot

Loading

wpt-pr-bot left a comment

w3c-bots commented Jul 4, 2017 •

edited

Loading

w3c-bots commented Jul 4, 2017 •

edited

Loading

w3c-bots commented Jul 4, 2017 •

edited

Loading

w3c-bots commented Jul 4, 2017 •

edited

Loading

mikewest commented Jul 5, 2017

w3c-bots commented Sep 18, 2017 •

edited

Loading

Trusted Types: Prototype for hacking. #6457

Trusted Types: Prototype for hacking. #6457

Conversation

chromium-wpt-export-bot commented Jul 4, 2017 • edited by wpt-pr-bot Loading

wpt-pr-bot left a comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

w3c-bots commented Jul 4, 2017 • edited Loading

Firefox (nightly)

All results

w3c-bots commented Jul 4, 2017 • edited Loading

Sauce (safari)

All results

w3c-bots commented Jul 4, 2017 • edited Loading

Chrome (unstable)

All results

w3c-bots commented Jul 4, 2017 • edited Loading

Sauce (MicrosoftEdge)

All results

mikewest commented Jul 5, 2017

w3c-bots commented Sep 18, 2017 • edited Loading

Build PASSED

chromium-wpt-export-bot commented Jul 4, 2017 •

edited by wpt-pr-bot

Loading

w3c-bots commented Jul 4, 2017 •

edited

Loading

w3c-bots commented Jul 4, 2017 •

edited

Loading

w3c-bots commented Jul 4, 2017 •

edited

Loading

w3c-bots commented Jul 4, 2017 •

edited

Loading

w3c-bots commented Sep 18, 2017 •

edited

Loading